When the engineer you want gets a counter offer
An engineer who resigns hands their manager a small arithmetic problem. One answer is a raise. The other is an empty seat, a search and months of someone new learning where everything is kept. The raise can look cheaper, so the manager offers it, which turns your offer into the opening bid in an auction you did not know you were running.
That is a counter offer, more or less. The current employer finds out late that its engineer has a price and names one. This is a perfectly sensible thing for it to do. It is also worth noticing that the employer who counters gets to bid last and with better information than you have. It knows the engineer. You know them from a few interviews and a reference call.
How the counter gets made
The sequence is simple. The engineer accepts your offer, writes the resignation email and tells their manager. The manager, who was not planning to run a search this quarter, goes to their own boss and to HR. Money that was unavailable at the last annual review becomes available on a Tuesday afternoon, because the question has changed. It used to be whether this engineer deserved more. Now it is what it costs to replace them.
The counter does not have to be money. It might be a promotion, a new title, a move to the project the engineer kept asking about, more remote days or a retention bonus that pays out if they stay a year. The employer is free to offer whatever it thinks the engineer actually wants, and it has years of one-on-one meetings to tell it what that is.
Quitting a job is ordinary. The Bureau of Labor Statistics counted 3.4 million quits across the US economy in September 2026. A manager does not fight over every departure, so a counter is a statement that this particular engineer is expensive to lose. You already believed that, since you were trying to hire them.
Why engineers take it
Staying is the default, and a counter makes the default better. The engineer keeps the systems they understand, the colleagues they trust and whatever bonus or stock is due to them next spring. They get the raise without the risk of starting over somewhere new, where they have to prove again that they are good at this. If money was the main reason they were looking, the counter removes the reason and leaves everything else in place, which is a hard deal to beat.
There is also a softer pull. Engineers leave mid-project, and the people left holding the project are friends. A manager who says the team needs you is usually telling the truth, and an engineer who hears it might feel that taking the raise is the decent thing to do.
Why engineers turn it down
Plenty of engineers are not leaving over money. Some want to design instead of maintain. Some want hardware that ships instead of a program that keeps getting delayed. Some would like to report to someone other than the person now offering them a raise. A counter that only adds salary answers a question they did not ask. The project is still delayed on Monday.
There is the awkward part too. The engineer has now told their employer, in writing, that they were ready to go. Some will wonder why the raise needed a resignation letter to appear, and whether the next one will need another. The counter can feel less like recognition and more like a price being paid to avoid a hiring problem, which is roughly what it is.
So a counter tends to work on engineers whose reason for leaving was money and tends to fail on engineers whose reason was something money cannot fix. That gives the hiring employer one job above all others, which is finding out early which kind of engineer this is.
Before the offer: find out why they are leaving
Ask in the first conversation why they are looking, then ask again near the end, because the answer gets more honest as people get to know you. A useful version is blunt. If your manager offered you a raise tomorrow, would you still be talking to us? The answer is not a promise, but an engineer who says yes and then names the work they want is telling you how to win.
Ask about pay expectations rather than current pay. If the job is in California, the state’s Labor Code section 432.3 bars employers from seeking an applicant’s salary history but lets them ask about salary expectations. An applicant may still volunteer their history without prompting. Expectations are the more useful number anyway, since they tell you what it takes to move the person instead of what their employer once decided to pay.
Then make the first offer the real one. If you would go higher after a counter, there is a decent case for going higher now. A raise that appears only after a counter teaches the engineer that your first number was not your best. It also gives them something new to take back to their current employer for a second round, and now you are in an auction for real.
Put the reasons in the offer, not only the salary. Name the project, the manager, the systems they would own and what the first six months look like. If the engineer said they want to design power distribution instead of maintaining it, the offer letter is a fine place to say they will be designing it. A counter can match a number in an afternoon. Matching a different job takes longer.
Finally, talk about the resignation before it happens. Ask what they expect their manager to say. An engineer who has already thought through the counter, and decided what would and would not change their mind, is much harder to talk out of leaving than one meeting the idea for the first time across a desk.
| When | What you do | Why it helps |
|---|---|---|
| First call | Ask why they are looking and whether a raise would keep them | Tells you whether the counter will be about money |
| Final interview | Ask again and let them meet the people they would work with | Gives them a reason to leave that a counter cannot copy |
| Offer | Lead with your best number and the specific work | Leaves you nothing to add later that looks like a concession |
| Before they resign | Ask what they expect their manager to offer | Lets them decide in advance instead of in the room |
| Notice period | Stay in touch and start onboarding early | Makes your team real before their last day |
After they resign: the counter arrives
Sometimes the engineer calls you back to say there is a counter. This is not bad news exactly. An engineer who calls you is still deciding, and one who had made up their mind to stay would more likely send a polite email.
Start with what changed, not with a number. Did the counter fix the thing they were leaving over, or did it add money to a job they still want to leave? If it was money, you have a pricing decision. If it was something else, the counter has not touched it. The most useful thing you can do then is say so plainly and remind them of the work they picked you for. In California, be careful about asking for the counter’s exact figure, since the statute bars seeking salary history information. Whether a counter counts is a question for your employment lawyer, and the engineer can always volunteer it.
Decide your top number before the call, not during it. If you raise once, the current employer can raise again. An engineer caught between two employers bidding against each other may end up taking whichever raise came last. A ceiling you set in advance keeps you from paying the person well above everyone else on the team just to win a contest.
Raising is reasonable when the gap is money and your first offer sat below what you would actually pay for this person. It is less reasonable when the counter added a title or a project you cannot match. Then the honest argument is about the work, and more salary mostly helps the engineer negotiate a bigger counter.
The notice period is part of the hire
Between the resignation and the first day, the engineer is still sitting at their old desk next to the manager who wanted them to stay. You might use that time well. Send the onboarding paperwork early, get the laptop shipped, set up lunch with a future teammate and share the first project brief. Each of these makes your company a little more like a place they already work, which is the main advantage their current employer had over you.
Keep the start date close if you can. A short gap leaves less time for a second counter, and it lets the engineer spend their notice handing off work instead of reconsidering.
Decide your ceiling before you need it
This week you could write down the most you would pay the engineer you are about to make an offer to. Next to it, write what you would say if their employer offered the job they actually want. Then add the question about a raise to your first screening call. If the search is for a software engineer or an electrical engineer, the screening questions on those practice pages are a good place to add it, right next to the questions about what the candidate actually built.


